A stone slate roof that has started to let in water is rarely a roof at the end of its life. Most often it is the fixings that have given up. Once that is clear, the question is how much of the roof has to come off to put it right.
Q2.1What actually fails on an old stone slate roof?
Oak pegs eventually rot. Battens soften where damp has been trapped. Mortar pointing at the gables dries and drops out, and the stones slip against each other. Cotswold District Council's guidance observes that when old roofs are stripped, a fair proportion of the slates are often found to have perished, so a careful survey of the stones is part of the job.
Q2.2How is a slipping slope lifted and re-laid?
A small patch of slipped stones is simply put back. A slope that is on the move needs lifting: the stones come off in order, are graded by size, the battens and underlay beneath are replaced, and the same stones go back in diminishing courses, with matching stone filling any shortfall. English Heritage policy, quoted in the same guide, is to prefer new stone slates to second-hand ones, and to keep salvaged stone for the roof it was taken off. We follow that approach and tell you where any stone comes from.
Q2.3Why not swap the stone for concrete tiles?
Concrete or reconstituted tiles look different and weigh differently. The policy quoted in the guide treats such substitutes as unsuitable for historic buildings, and the stone and the village would both show the difference. If your roof is already covered in something else, we can talk through options, and our roof replacement guide sets out when a complete new covering is the right answer, and what it means for the structure beneath.
Maintenance counts for a good deal. A roof that is looked at every few years and fixed in small steps costs less over time than one left until an entire slope needs lifting. Clearing moss from the gutters and valleys each autumn, and checking the gable ends after a windy spell, are the sort of small habits that keep water out of the timbers.