The short answer
Usually a careful repair rather than a new roof. Houses with fifteenth-century or seventeenth-century parts have several roof planes, valleys and chimneys, and most leaks start at the junctions between them. Fixing those, and renewing battens and underlay where they have failed, often keeps the covering.
Ashbury Manor House has a fifteenth-century core and a porch whose brick upper storey was added in 1697. The house is a good picture of what happens to old buildings: they grow. Each addition brings another roof, and each join between roofs is a place a leak can start.
Q1.1Why do valleys and junctions leak first?
A valley is the angle where two roof slopes meet and run water down between them. In older houses it may be lined with lead, felt or a mortar-bedded tile, and it gathers the run-off from both slopes, so it works harder than the plain tiling beside it. A cracked valley lining can drip into a bedroom for months before anyone traces it back. We open up the valley, check the lining and the tiles either side, and repair or renew only that run.
Q1.2Why does lead at an old stack split?
Chimney stacks on old houses are tall, and their flashings are cut into joints between stones or bricks. Lead at a stack lasts for decades, but it splits where it has been folded repeatedly, and where mortar around it has crumbled the lead can lift. Re-fixing the lead and re-pointing the joint is light work if the problem is found early, and it turns into a stained ceiling and a plaster repair if it is left through another winter. A stack that leans, or bricks that crumble when touched, is a different conversation, and we raise it plainly once we have looked at it from the ladder.
Q1.3Are the battens and underlay still sound?
Modern underlay was not available when many old roofs were built. If a roof has been re-felted at some stage, the felt may be torn or perished, and battens beneath tiles can have softened. A soft batten gives under a thumb or a screwdriver tip, while a sound one stays firm; the survey checks several along each slope.
Our lead roofing page covers valleys, flashings and soakers in more detail. Photographs from the survey show each of these places close up, so the written quote can point to the exact spot behind its price, and you can decide what to do with the roof itself in view.