The short answer
Because the covering is hand-split limestone hung in sizes that shrink up the slope, held by pegs, and carried on timbers that have settled over centuries. A roofer who treats it like modern tile will lift more than is needed, mix the wrong stone in and leave a patch that never blends.
Cirencester sits at the point where the Cotswold Hills meet the upper Thames valley, on the site of Roman Corinium, and the stone under its roofs comes from the same geology as the walls below them. The council's town centre appraisal treats that continuity as the thing that makes the centre what it is.
Q1.1Why is the stone graded up the roof?
Cotswold District Council's technical guidance, dating from April 2000, explains the logic. Quarried stone splits into many more small pieces than large ones. The builders therefore sized the roof to suit the supply: the longest slates, about 600 mm and sometimes more, sit low in a doubled course called cussoms, followers come next, and the shortest pieces, called short cocks, finish the top.
Q1.2How heavy and steep are these roofs?
The same guidance puts the weight at about 1000 kg per 10 square metres, and describes simple roofs pitched at roughly 47 to 55 degrees. Our method on these roofs follows from that: we protect the rafters, spread our own loads, and avoid walking on slates that cannot take it.
Q1.3Where do problems start?
Fixings tend to give way before the stone does, and moss keeps courses wet. Wet stone freezes and flakes. Early attention to pegs, battens and the lead at chimneys keeps a roof going for generations, and the council's guidance says an annual scrape of moss and debris can make the roof last twice as long. Our Cotswold stone roofing page goes through the work step by step.
A survey here takes longer than on a tile roof, and the photographs show it: every slope, the ridge, the valleys, each chimney and the loft. That level of detail lets the written quote separate the few slates that need rehanging from the courses that are perfectly sound.