When a stone-tiled roof is stripped, some of the tiles will have perished, and the question of where replacements come from is a real one. The policy quoted in the council's guidance is clear about the principle.
Q2.1Can the stones go back on the same building?
Its rule for second-hand slates is simple: they go back on the building, or the group of buildings, that they came off, and nowhere else. That makes sense: the stones are the right size and colour, and nothing has been taken from a neighbour. On a Castle Eaton cottage, the sound tiles are set aside during stripping, sorted by size and put back, so the roof keeps its own character.
Q2.2Where does new stone come in?
Perished stones are made up with new slates of the same type. The guidance warns against ever combining sandstone with limestone on one roof, and says sawn slates can look and perform badly. Concrete and reconstituted substitutes are described there as unsuitable for historic buildings. Our page on reclaimed and new stone sets out the choice in full.
Q2.3Why does provenance matter?
Old stone is sometimes stolen from other roofs, which is why we ask where any reclaimed material came from before using it, and choose new stone where the history is doubtful. A roof on a Castle Eaton cottage should not be built from somebody else's missing slates.
The survey photographs show which stones are sound and which are failing, so the written quote covers only what needs to change. You can compare progress against those pictures while the scaffold is up, and nothing is thrown away without being shown to you first.