The short answer
By keeping the stones and renewing what holds them. Pegs, battens and bedding fail first, so a careful repair refixes slipped stones, replaces rotten fixings and re-lays courses with matching reclaimed stone only where a stone is broken. Stripping a whole slope is the last resort, not the first.
Stone tiles are heavy and old. The appraisal lists them on the church, the Manor House, West Hill House, the Old Rectory and Teapot Cottage, and the village's cottages once carried them too. Roofs like these ask for patience.
Q1.1Why do stones slip?
A stone tile hangs from a peg through a hole near its head, resting on a batten. Over decades the peg rots or the batten softens and the stone slides. The stone itself may be perfectly sound. Moss packs the gaps between courses and holds moisture against the timber, which makes things worse. Each slipped stone opens a gap for rain, and if left alone the stones around it follow.
Q1.2Can a stone be refixed rather than replaced?
The first question on a visit is whether a stone can be refixed rather than replaced. Often it can, with a new peg or a stainless fixing that does the same job. Where a stone has split, a replacement of matching thickness and size goes in the same course. Stones are laid in diminishing courses, so the big ones sit at the eaves and the small ones near the ridge, and a stone of the wrong size cannot simply be dropped in.
Q1.3When does a slope have to come apart?
Where battens and fixings have failed across an entire slope, the right answer is a careful strip: stones lifted off and graded into piles by size, new timber fixed, and the stones laid back in order. We photograph the roof before anything comes off so the pattern is recorded. Our Cotswold stone roofing page explains the method in more detail, and the roof repairs page covers smaller faults.
Sourcing matters as well. Reclaimed stone is matched by thickness, size and colour, and we say where it came from, so you are never left wondering whether your new stones came off another building's roof.