The short answer
The walls are limestone, but the roofs above them vary. Some old buildings carry stone slates, others clay tiles, natural slate or later concrete tiles. Nobody can tell from the road, so we identify the covering at the survey and choose a repair that suits it.
Box lies in the Bath stone belt. Beds of oolitic limestone run under the parish, the stone was quarried here for a century or more, and it went into the walls of the village. It is easy to assume the roofs followed the walls. They did not always, and a survey that starts from an assumption can go wrong. The covering might be stone slate on one house, clay on the next and slate or concrete tile on a third, sometimes all within the same lane.
Q1.1How can you tell a stone slate roof from a lookalike?
Real stone slates are uneven in thickness and outline. The biggest slabs lie low along the bottom edge, with sizes dwindling as you look towards the ridge, each stone dangling from a peg that passes through a hole near its top. Concrete lookalikes are made to a regular pattern and have a flatter, more uniform face. The difference matters, because English Heritage policy, as the Cotswold District Council technical guide records, treats substitutes as unsuitable for historic buildings. Our Cotswold stone roofing page sets out how that work is carried out.
Q1.2What happens to the stones when a roof is stripped?
Salvaged slates belong, ideally, back on the building that supplied them. Taking them off another house to patch yours can strip that house of its own roof. When we lift a stone roof, each sound stone is graded by size and returned to its place, with any gap made up from stock that matches in type and colour. Limestone and sandstone slates are not mixed.
Q1.3Why do the gables and chimneys matter so much?
On stone buildings, the copings, kneelers and stacks are part of the roof's watertightness. Open joints let moisture into the wall head, and stained stonework below a gable is often the first sign of trouble. Our photographs cover those details as well as the roof slopes, and they travel with the quote.