A leaking stone roof is rarely a failure of the stone itself. The wood behind it gives way first: pegs perish, battens soften and the stones drop out of line. The booklet records that, once a roof like this is stripped, about half the slates have often decayed, which means a re-lay is never a plain exchange of old for new.
Q2.1Which stone goes back onto a Northleach roof?
The English Heritage position, printed in that booklet, is to favour newly cut stone over used, and to put salvaged stone back only where it came from, on the same building or group. Pulling stone off one building to roof another simply strips the first. The same policy bars swapping sandstone for limestone slates or mixing them, and warns that sawn slates can look and perform wrongly.
Q2.2What do stone roofs cost?
A Checkatrade guide, last updated in September 2026, gives about £160 to £210 per square metre for stone slate on an average roof, a number not tied to the Cotswolds. Natural slate ranges from MyBuilder sit beside it. After the survey comes a written quote, with prices that are good and fair.
Q2.3Why scrape a stone roof every year?
The guidance says yearly scraping could double a roof's life, because moss and debris go before they hold water against the stone. That is historic advice and a guide, not a promise, yet it explains why light regular attention beats waiting for a leak. Our roof repairs page shows how we separate quick fixes from jobs that need more.
If a leak cannot wait for the full works, we stop the water first and then plan the proper repair around that. In a town where many roofs are heavy, old and difficult to reach, that sequence keeps the building dry while the right stone, the right pegs and the right weather are found.