The short answer
Wiltshire Council is the planning authority, and it decides listed building consent. St Laurence church, Hilmarton Manor, the school and the almshouses are all listed, so changes to their roofs that affect character need consent. Like-for-like repairs are the usual starting point, and the council can say what counts.
Hilmarton's church of St Laurence, still in use as a Church of England parish church, was listed Grade I in 1960. It was first mentioned in 1291 and has a north arcade from the late 12th century. Hilmarton Manor, the village school from about 1860 and five almshouses of 1877 are Grade II. The village also has a conservation area designated by Wiltshire Council.
Q1.1What needs listed building consent?
Listed building consent applies to works that would affect a building's character as a building of special interest. A new covering, a different ridge detail or a change to chimneys can all count. Putting back what was there, with the same materials and the same method, normally does not alter the character, though the council has the last word and it is sensible to ask.
Q1.2What counts as like for like?
Same material means the same type, size and colour, not merely the same family. Welsh slate is replaced with Welsh slate of matching size, and clay tile with clay tile of a similar tone. Lead stays lead, and old nails and clips are renewed behind it. Our slate roofing page sets out how slates are matched and re-laid.
Q1.3Does the church follow the same rules as its neighbours?
For St Laurence, changes follow the diocese's faculty system while the church is in use, and the parish's architect guides that process. The same does not apply to the school, almshouses or manor, which go through the council in the usual way. Where a building has been converted to a house, the council's rules apply to the house.
Whichever route applies, the written quote describes the work and comes with photographs of the existing roof. That gives the council, or your architect, something concrete to consider before anything is decided, and it avoids a misunderstanding about what is being changed.
When you contact us, say if the building is listed. It changes how we plan the work, what we photograph and which questions go to the council first.