A repair is worth doing when it stops the fault and leaves the roof sounder than before. Near a church of this age, it is also the approach that keeps the street looking right.
Q2.1When is a repair enough?
Slipped tiles, a cracked ridge, a flashing that has lifted or a valley choked with debris are all repairable. Where the surrounding covering is still in good order, a repair can add many years. We replace what has failed with tiles or slates matched for size, colour and texture, and we refix those that have slipped.
Q2.2When is a re-cover the honest answer?
If tiles are crumbling, laminating or cracking across the whole slope, repairs become a treadmill. Each winter another batch goes. At that point a new covering costs less than a run of call-outs. We strip the slope, inspect the battens and rafters, renew what is rotten, fit a modern underlay and relay on new battens.
Q2.3What do underlay and ventilation add?
Old roofs were never lined, so the first thing an owner notices after a re-cover is how much less dust and draught comes through. A breathable underlay and the correct eaves ventilation keep the roof space dry in winter. BS 5250 covers how a cold roof is ventilated, and we follow the covering manufacturer's guidance for the product chosen.
Our roof replacement page sets out what moves the cost of a new covering, from access and scaffold to the tile you choose. In a quiet village the practical details count too: where the skip stands, how deliveries reach the house along a narrow lane, and how neighbours are kept informed. We plan those before the first tile comes off, then leave the lane and garden swept once the last load has gone.